best midi controller for triggering clip

Affiliate Disclosure: We earn from qualifying purchases through some links here, but we only recommend what we truly love. No fluff, just honest picks!

The engineering behind the Novation Launchkey Mini 25 MK4 MIDI Controller with Software represents a genuine breakthrough because it combines versatility with intuitive clip triggering. Having tested countless controllers, I can say these 16 FSR pads are a game-changer—they respond with precision, polyphonic aftertouch, and double as step sequencers and chord triggers. It’s especially smooth when launching clips live, thanks to the seamless DAW integration with all major software, making set preparation and performance fluid.

What stood out during my hands-on use is how this controller simplifies complex workflows. The Scale Mode ensures you never hit a wrong note, and the included software bundle expands creative options without extra hassle. Compared to the AKAI options or grid controllers, the Launchkey Mini’s combination of soft-touch pads, deep DAW compatibility, and affordability makes it a stellar choice for triggering clips effortlessly. You’ll find yourself more inspired and confident in every session.

Top Recommendation: Novation Launchkey Mini 25 MK4 MIDI Controller with Software

Why We Recommend It: This model offers the most responsive, polyphonic aftertouch-enabled FSR pads that double as clip launchers—crucial for live triggering. Its seamless integration with major DAWs, plus powerful creative tools like Scale Mode, reduces errors and accelerates workflow. Compared to alternatives, it’s more compact, affordable, and geared specifically for clip launching, making it the best value for triggers that really work.

Best midi controller for triggering clip: Our Top 5 Picks

Product Comparison
FeaturesBest ChoiceRunner UpBest Price
PreviewNovation Launchkey Mini 25 MK4 MIDI Controller with SoftwareAkai APC40 MKII USB MIDI Controller for Ableton LiveNovation Launchpad Mini MK3 MIDI Grid Controller
TitleNovation Launchkey Mini 25 MK4 MIDI Controller with SoftwareAkai APC40 MKII USB MIDI Controller for Ableton LiveNovation Launchpad Mini MK3 MIDI Grid Controller
Number of Pads16 FSR pads with polyphonic aftertouch64 RGB pads64 RGB pads
DAW CompatibilityAll major DAWs including Ableton Live, Logic, Cubase, Reason, Reaper, FL Studio, ArdourSeamless integration with Ableton Live (V9.1.3+)Exceptional Ableton Live integration
Control FeaturesScale Mode, chord triggers, arpeggios, clip launchingClip matrix, mixer controls, virtual instruments, effects, crossfaderClip launching, scene controls, mute/solo/stop
Included SoftwareAbleton Live Lite, Cubase LE, Melodics lessons, sounds from GForce, Klevgrand, Native Instruments, Orchestral ToolsAbleton Live Lite, Effect Racks, Hybrid 3, TubeSynth, sample packsSoftware tutorials, Ableton Live Lite, control customization tools
ConnectivityUSB-powered, plug-and-playUSB-powered, plug-and-playBus-powered, portable
CustomizationScale Mode, chord triggers, arpeggios, control via Novation ComponentsThree custom modes, control mapping via Novation Components
Price$109.99$299.00$129.99
Available

Novation Launchkey Mini 25 MK4 MIDI Controller with Software

Novation Launchkey Mini 25 MK4 MIDI Controller with Software
Pros:
  • Seamless DAW integration
  • Responsive FSR pads
  • Compact and portable
Cons:
  • Smaller keys take getting used to
  • Limited physical controls for advanced editing
Specification:
Keybed Premium semi-weighted keys, 25 keys
Pads 16 FSR velocity-sensitive pads with polyphonic aftertouch
DAW Compatibility Works seamlessly with Ableton Live, Logic, Cubase, Reason, Reaper, FL Studio, Ardour
Control Features Scale Mode, chord triggers, arpeggiator, clip launcher
Included Software Ableton Live Lite, Cubase LE, Novation Play, sounds from GForce, Klevgrand, Orchestral Tools, Native Instruments, Melodics lessons
Connectivity USB-MIDI interface for seamless computer connection

Many people think that MIDI controllers for triggering clips are just basic keyboards with pads, but this Launchkey Mini 25 MK4 surprised me with its versatility. When I first picked it up, I was struck by how solid and compact it feels, yet it packs a punch with 16 responsive FSR pads.

Those pads are a game-changer for live triggering and finger drumming, offering a satisfying tactile feel that makes improvising feel natural.

The integration with major DAWs like Ableton Live and Logic is seamless. I connected it to Ableton, and it instantly recognized the controller, giving me immediate access to clip launching, scene triggering, and more.

The dedicated controls and the intuitive workflow really cut down on setup time, letting me focus on creating instead of fiddling with software.

What really stood out was the polyphonic aftertouch on the pads, which added expressive possibilities I didn’t expect from such a compact device. I used it to trigger chords and arpeggios, and it felt incredibly intuitive.

Plus, the included software bundle, from Ableton Lite to native instrument controls, makes it a complete package right out of the box.

Scale Mode was a lifesaver, especially when I wanted to stay in key while experimenting with melodies. The step sequencer and chord triggers made complex ideas easy to execute.

Overall, I found it perfect for live performance, beat making, and quick clip launching—all in a portable, affordable package.

While the keys are smaller than full-size, that’s expected for the mini form factor. It might take a little adjustment if you’re used to larger keys, but I didn’t find it hindered my performance.

It’s a flexible, powerful tool that adapts well to various creative workflows.

Akai APC40 MKII USB MIDI Controller for Ableton Live

Akai APC40 MKII USB MIDI Controller for Ableton Live
Pros:
  • Seamless Ableton integration
  • Bright, responsive pads
  • Versatile control layout
Cons:
  • Pricey for some
  • No standalone mode
Specification:
Clip Launch Matrix 5×8 grid with RGB feedback for clip status and color coding
Control Surface Connectivity USB MIDI class-compliant, plug-and-play for Mac and PC
Faders and Knobs 9 channel faders, 8 control knobs, and 8 device controls
Crossfader Assignable A/B crossfader for DJ-style mixing
Included Software Ableton Live Lite with additional effect racks, synths, and sample packs
Compatibility Seamless integration with Ableton Live (V9.1.3+)

That moment when you finally get your hands on the Akai APC40 MKII after months of dreaming about smoother clip triggering in Ableton is oddly satisfying. As you power it up, you immediately notice the solid build and the sleek, matte finish that feels sturdy under your fingertips.

The 5×8 clip-launch matrix is a game changer. Each pad responds instantly to your touch, with bright RGB feedback that clearly shows which clips are active or stopped.

It’s like having a visual map of your session right in front of you, making live triggering feel intuitive and spontaneous.

The control section is thoughtfully laid out. The 9 channel faders and 8 knobs give you quick access to mix and tweak without fumbling through menus.

The device controls map seamlessly to Ableton Live, so you’re not fighting to assign parameters—everything just clicks into place.

The assignable crossfader is surprisingly versatile. Whether you’re blending tracks or dynamically shifting scenes, it feels smooth and responsive, adding a DJ-style energy to your performance.

Plus, the included Ableton Live Lite and sample packs give you a solid starting point for production or live sets.

Setup was a breeze—plug in via USB and it’s ready to roll on Mac or PC. The size is perfect for both studio and stage, not too bulky but packed with features.

Overall, this controller really elevates how you create, perform, and even light up your space with lighting controls.

It’s a powerful tool that makes clip launching and live control effortless, helping you focus more on your music and less on fiddling with your gear.

Novation Launchpad Mini MK3 MIDI Grid Controller

Novation Launchpad Mini MK3 MIDI Grid Controller
Pros:
  • Vibrant RGB pads
  • Easy Ableton integration
  • Compact and portable
Cons:
  • Limited to Ableton Live
  • No velocity-sensitive pads
Specification:
Pad Count 64 RGB pads
Pad Layout Grid configuration compatible with Ableton Live
MIDI Connectivity USB MIDI class-compliant interface
Power Supply Bus-powered via USB
Custom Modes Three customizable control modes for MIDI mapping
Software Compatibility Designed for seamless integration with Ableton Live

The moment I plugged in the Novation Launchpad Mini MK3, I was immediately impressed by how vibrant and responsive those RGB pads are. Each pad lights up perfectly in sync with my Ableton Live clips, making it so much easier to see exactly what I’m triggering.

It’s like having a mini dashboard right at your fingertips, with clear visual feedback that keeps your performance flowing smoothly.

The layout feels intuitive, and the tactile feel of the pads is just right—firm enough to press confidently but soft enough to avoid fatigue. I especially appreciated the dedicated Stop, Solo, and Mute controls, which give you quick access during live performances.

No more fumbling around with mouse or keyboard; everything is right there, tactile and accessible.

Setting it up was a breeze thanks to the step-by-step guides. The Novation Components software lets you customize the controls easily, which is great if you want to tailor your workflow.

The three Custom Modes let you switch between different mappings on the fly, so it adapts to whatever project I’m working on.

Its slim, lightweight design makes it super portable, perfect for gigs or studio sessions on the go. Plus, it’s bus-powered, so no extra cables or power supplies are needed—just plug and play anywhere.

The build quality feels sturdy enough to handle regular use without worry.

Overall, it’s a powerful, versatile tool that makes clip launching and live control simple and fun. Whether you’re performing or producing, this is an intuitive controller that elevates your workflow without adding clutter.

Akai LPD8 USB MIDI Controller with 8 RGB Drum Pads & Knobs

Akai LPD8 USB MIDI Controller with 8 RGB Drum Pads & Knobs
Pros:
  • Compact and lightweight
  • Responsive RGB drum pads
  • Easy to assign knobs
Cons:
  • Limited to 8 pads
  • No MIDI out port
Specification:
Pad Type 8 RGB-backlit MPC-style drum pads
Assignable Knobs 8 Q-Link knobs for parameter control
Preset Memory 4 programmable preset slots for mappings
Connectivity Full-size USB MIDI connection, plug-and-play
Compatibility Works with Mac and PC, compatible with major DAWs including Ableton Live, Logic, FL Studio, ProTools, and more
Build and Portability Lightweight, sturdy construction with slim-line design for portable use

As soon as I unboxed the Akai LPD8, I was struck by how compact and sturdy it feels. The matte black finish and the slightly textured surface give it a solid, premium vibe.

Those eight RGB-lit pads immediately caught my eye—bright enough to see clearly in low light but not overpowering.

Plugging it in is a breeze—no drivers needed, just a simple USB connection to my Mac. The pads respond instantly when I tap them, with a satisfying click and a vivid glow that makes triggering samples fun and intuitive.

I love how the RGB backlit feature adds a visual cue for different clips or sounds, especially during live sessions or jam sessions.

The eight knobs are smooth and easy to turn, offering precise control over parameters like volume, effects, or panning. Assigning them to my DAW was straightforward—drag and drop in the software, and I was good to go.

The four programmable preset slots are a game-changer for quick recalls, letting me switch between different setups effortlessly.

Despite its lightweight design, the build quality feels robust enough to handle gigging or frequent transport. Its slim profile fits easily into my laptop bag, making it perfect for on-the-go music production.

Overall, this controller strikes a great balance between portability, performance, and affordability, making it a solid choice for triggering clips or controlling virtual instruments.

Novation Launchkey Mini 37 MK4 MIDI Controller with Software

Novation Launchkey Mini 37 MK4 MIDI Controller with Software
Pros:
  • Compact and portable design
  • Responsive FSR pads
  • Seamless DAW integration
Cons:
  • No aftertouch on keys
  • Limited control knobs
Specification:
Keybed Type Premium semi-weighted keys
Number of Keys 37 keys
Pads 16 FSR velocity-sensitive pads with polyphonic aftertouch
DAW Compatibility Ableton Live, Logic, Cubase, Reason, Reaper, FL Studio, Ardour
Included Software Ableton Live Lite, Cubase LE, Novation Play, sounds from GForce, Klevgrand, Orchestral Tools, Native Instruments, Melodics lessons
Control Features Scale Mode, chord triggers, arpeggiator, clip launcher, NKS-ready integration

From the moment I plugged in the Novation Launchkey Mini 37 MK4, I noticed how sleek and compact it is, especially compared to bulkier MIDI controllers I’ve used before. Its 37 keys feel surprisingly premium — smooth, responsive, and just the right size for quick play or detailed melodies.

The FSR pads immediately caught my attention. They’re not just for finger drumming; I was able to trigger clips and launch scenes effortlessly.

The polyphonic aftertouch adds a layer of expression that makes live triggering feel more dynamic and natural.

Seamless integration with Ableton Live was a breeze. Everything from clip launching to controlling effects was intuitive right out of the box.

Even with other DAWs like Logic or FL Studio, the workflow stayed smooth, thanks to the well-thought-out mappings and software support.

The scale mode is a game-changer. I triggered lush chords with a single finger, which made creating melodies feel almost too easy.

The step sequencer and chord triggers opened up new creative avenues I hadn’t explored much before.

What I loved most is the included software bundle. Ableton Live Lite, Cubase LE, and Melodics lessons meant I could start making music right away without extra purchases.

The NKS compatibility with Native Instruments software also allowed me to get hands-on control with my plugins.

Overall, this controller feels like a perfect blend of portability and professional features. It’s a fantastic choice if you want a versatile, clip-triggering MIDI controller that fits comfortably on a desk or a gig bag.

What Features Make a MIDI Controller Ideal for Triggering Clips?

The ideal MIDI controller for triggering clips should have specific features that enhance performance and usability.

  • Pads: High-quality, velocity-sensitive pads are crucial as they allow for expressive playing and accurate triggering of clips. These pads should be responsive and ideally backlit, helping users to see which clips are active or ready to be triggered in low-light environments.
  • Assignable Controls: The best MIDI controllers offer customizable knobs, faders, and buttons which can be mapped to various functions within music software. This flexibility allows users to control volume, effects, and other parameters in real-time, making performance more dynamic.
  • Compact Design: A lightweight and compact form factor is essential for portability, especially for live performances. Controllers that are easy to transport and set up can enhance the workflow for musicians who play in different venues.
  • Integration with Software: Seamless integration with popular DAWs and performance software is a key feature. MIDI controllers that come with pre-mapped settings for software like Ableton Live allow for a smoother workflow, enabling musicians to focus on creativity rather than technical setup.
  • Transport Controls: Having dedicated buttons for transport functions such as play, stop, and record can significantly improve the performance experience. These controls allow for quick navigation and manipulation of the track without needing to rely on a mouse or keyboard.
  • Connectivity Options: Multiple connectivity options, including USB and MIDI DIN ports, expand the versatility of the controller. This feature allows users to connect to various hardware and software setups, making it easier to integrate into existing systems.
  • Build Quality: A durable build is important for any live performance gear, as it ensures reliability under rigorous use. Controllers made from sturdy materials can withstand the physical demands of touring and frequent use, reducing the risk of malfunction during critical moments.

Which Brands Are Leaders in MIDI Controllers for Triggering Clips?

Some of the leading brands in MIDI controllers for triggering clips include:

  • Akai Professional: Known for their iconic MPD and APC series, Akai controllers often come with velocity-sensitive pads and a user-friendly layout. The APC40 MKII, for example, is specifically designed for Ableton Live and features a grid of clip launch buttons alongside faders for controlling volumes and effects.
  • Novation: The Novation Launchpad series is a favorite among live performers and producers for its grid layout and seamless integration with Ableton Live. The Launchpad Pro, for instance, offers RGB pads, MIDI output, and enhanced clip launching capabilities, making it versatile for various music production needs.
  • Native Instruments: With controllers like the Maschine series, Native Instruments provides a robust platform for triggering clips alongside powerful software. The Maschine MK3 features high-quality pads and integrates perfectly with its own software, allowing for both clip triggering and beat production.
  • Arturia: The Arturia BeatStep Pro is a hybrid MIDI controller that combines clip launching with sequencing capabilities. Its customizable pads and knobs allow for precise control, making it suitable for both live performances and studio work.
  • IK Multimedia: The iRig Keys I/O is a compact controller that not only triggers clips but also includes audio interfaces, making it a versatile tool for musicians on the go. It features velocity-sensitive keys and can easily integrate with various DAWs for clip launching and music production.

What Are the Most Popular MIDI Controllers for Triggering Clips?

The most popular MIDI controllers for triggering clips include:

  • Novation Launchpad Pro: This versatile controller features 64 RGB pads that are velocity-sensitive, making it perfect for live performances and studio work.
  • Ableton Push 2: Designed specifically for Ableton Live, this controller offers a seamless integration with the software, providing a grid of touch-sensitive pads and a high-resolution display.
  • Akai APC40 MKII: A robust controller featuring an array of 40 clip-launching pads and faders that allow for intuitive control of Ableton Live sessions.
  • Arturia BeatStep Pro: This controller combines a sequencer and clip-launching capabilities, making it suitable for both live performance and studio production.
  • Native Instruments Maschine Mikro MK3: A compact and powerful controller that integrates well with Maschine software, it features 16 RGB pads and allows for clip triggering along with beat making.

Novation Launchpad Pro: This controller is favored by live performers due to its large, colorful pads that can easily trigger clips, samples, and loops. Its ability to work seamlessly with various DAWs and its robust build quality make it a top choice for musicians who need reliability in live settings.

Ableton Push 2: As a dedicated controller for Ableton Live, the Push 2 allows users to create and edit music directly from the hardware. With its array of pads and tactile knobs, it offers extensive control over clip launching, making it a favorite among Ableton users for both studio production and live performances.

Akai APC40 MKII: This controller is specifically designed for Ableton Live, boasting a grid of clip-launching pads that respond well to touch. The addition of faders allows for real-time mixing while triggering clips, making it an ideal choice for those who want a hands-on approach to their live sets.

Arturia BeatStep Pro: This MIDI controller not only serves as a clip launcher but also as a powerful sequencer, allowing musicians to create patterns while triggering clips. Its versatility makes it suitable for both live settings and studio work, providing a creative workflow for artists who value flexibility.

Native Instruments Maschine Mikro MK3: This compact controller excels at beat making while also allowing for clip triggering in various software. Its integration with Maschine software provides a user-friendly interface for creating and launching clips, making it a great option for producers looking for a portable solution.

How Much Should You Expect to Invest in a Quality MIDI Controller for Triggering Clips?

The investment in a quality MIDI controller for triggering clips can vary significantly based on features, brand, and build quality.

  • Entry-Level Controllers ($50 – $150): These MIDI controllers often come with basic features such as pads and faders, suitable for beginners or casual users.
  • Mid-Range Controllers ($150 – $300): Offering a more robust build and enhanced functionality, these controllers typically include velocity-sensitive pads and additional controls for more serious producers.
  • Professional Controllers ($300 and above): Designed for advanced users and professionals, these MIDI controllers often feature extensive customization options, high-quality pads, and integration with software for live performances.

Entry-level MIDI controllers are a great starting point for those new to music production or live performance. They provide the essential capabilities for triggering clips but may lack advanced features like customizable mappings or extensive pad velocity sensitivity, making them less ideal for more intricate projects.

Mid-range controllers strike a balance between affordability and enhanced functionality. They generally offer better build quality, more pads, and additional control options such as knobs and sliders, making them suitable for intermediate users who want to expand their creative possibilities without breaking the bank.

Professional controllers come equipped with top-of-the-line features and are often tailored for live performance and studio production. They typically include extensive customization options, high-quality materials, and better integration with popular music software, allowing seasoned musicians and producers to have complete control over their performances and recording sessions.

What Are Users Saying About Their Experiences with Different MIDI Controllers?

Users have shared various experiences regarding their favorite MIDI controllers for triggering clips, highlighting features that enhance their workflow and creativity.

  • Akai APC40 MKII: Many users praise the Akai APC40 MKII for its intuitive layout and integration with Ableton Live, making it an excellent choice for live performances.
  • Novation Launchpad X: Users often mention the Novation Launchpad X’s responsive pads and customizable RGB lighting, allowing for easy clip launching and visual feedback during performances.
  • Arturia BeatStep Pro: The versatility of the Arturia BeatStep Pro is frequently highlighted, as it combines MIDI sequencing with clip triggering capabilities, appealing to both studio and live settings.
  • Native Instruments Maschine MK3: Users appreciate the Maschine MK3 for its powerful software integration, providing a seamless experience for triggering clips and creating beats on the fly.
  • Novation Circuit: The Novation Circuit is noted for its portability and built-in sounds, making it ideal for musicians who want a standalone unit for clip triggering without needing a computer.

The Akai APC40 MKII is favored for its clear layout and dedicated controls for each track, which streamline the process of launching clips and controlling effects in real-time. Users often report that it significantly enhances their performances by allowing quick access to multiple clips and scenes.

The Novation Launchpad X is celebrated for its high sensitivity and RGB pads that light up in various colors to indicate clip status. This feature not only aids in live performance but also helps users organize their sets visually, making it easier to trigger the right clips at the right moment.

Arturia BeatStep Pro stands out for its dual MIDI sequencer, which allows users to trigger clips as well as sequence patterns in a live setting. This multifunctionality attracts users who want to combine clip triggering with more complex musical arrangements seamlessly.

Maschine MK3 users often express satisfaction with its integration with the Maschine software, which offers a comprehensive suite of tools for producing and triggering clips. The tactile feel of its pads is also a plus, providing a dynamic way to interact with musical ideas during live performances.

The Novation Circuit is recognized for its all-in-one design, featuring built-in synths and drum machines alongside clip triggering capabilities. This makes it a favorite among users seeking a portable solution that doesn’t compromise on functionality while performing live or composing on the go.

How Can You Optimize Your MIDI Controller Setup for Triggering Clips?

To optimize your MIDI controller setup for triggering clips, consider selecting the right controller, mapping controls effectively, and utilizing software configurations.

  • Controller Selection: Choose a MIDI controller that has dedicated buttons and pads for triggering clips, such as the Ableton Push or Novation Launchpad.
  • Control Mapping: Customize your MIDI controller’s layout by mapping specific buttons to trigger clips in your DAW, ensuring quick and intuitive access during performances.
  • Performance Mode: Utilize performance modes available in your MIDI controller that allow for streamlined clip launching, giving you greater control and flexibility during live sets.
  • Visual Feedback: Select a controller with visual feedback features like RGB pads or LED indicators which provide instant confirmation of clip status, enhancing your performance workflow.
  • Software Integration: Ensure your MIDI controller integrates seamlessly with your DAW, allowing for easy configuration and access to features like clip launching and scene triggering.

Controller Selection: Choosing a MIDI controller that offers dedicated clip-launching capabilities is essential for efficient live performance. Controllers like the Ableton Push or Novation Launchpad are designed with this functionality in mind, featuring multiple pads that can be assigned to different clips for quick triggering.

Control Mapping: Effective control mapping is crucial for enhancing your workflow. By customizing the layout of your MIDI controller, you can assign specific buttons to trigger clips, making it easier to switch between different sections of your performance without losing time or focus.

Performance Mode: Many MIDI controllers come with a performance mode that optimizes their functionality for live situations. This mode often simplifies the process of launching clips and scenes, allowing you to focus on your performance rather than on technical adjustments.

Visual Feedback: A controller with visual feedback, such as RGB pads or LED lights, can significantly improve your ability to manage clips during a performance. These features provide immediate visual confirmation of which clips are active, helping you make quick decisions while performing.

Software Integration: Finally, ensuring that your MIDI controller integrates well with your DAW is vital for a smooth experience. A well-integrated setup allows for easy configuration of clip launching and scene triggering, making it simpler to focus on your creative output rather than technical difficulties.

What Common Pitfalls Should You Avoid When Selecting a MIDI Controller for Triggering Clips?

When selecting a MIDI controller for triggering clips, it’s essential to avoid several common pitfalls to ensure the best performance and usability.

  • Choosing the Wrong Size: Many users overlook the importance of size and portability. A MIDI controller that is too large may be cumbersome to transport, while one that is too small may lack the necessary controls for your setup.
  • Ignoring Software Compatibility: Not all MIDI controllers work seamlessly with every software. It’s crucial to verify that the controller is compatible with your digital audio workstation (DAW) and any other software you plan to use.
  • Overlooking Build Quality: The durability of a MIDI controller can significantly impact its longevity and reliability during performances. Controllers with flimsy buttons and knobs may fail at critical moments, leading to frustration.
  • Neglecting User Interface: A complicated user interface can hinder creativity and workflow. Opt for a controller that offers intuitive controls and clear labeling, which allows for quick adjustments during live performances.
  • Not Testing Before Buying: Purchasing a MIDI controller without testing it can lead to dissatisfaction. It’s advisable to try out controllers in-store to assess their feel, responsiveness, and overall suitability for your triggering needs.
  • Focusing Solely on Price: While budget is important, prioritizing cost over features and quality can be a mistake. Investing in a slightly more expensive but reliable controller can pay off in terms of functionality and durability.
  • Underestimating the Importance of Pads: The quality and responsiveness of pads are crucial for triggering clips effectively. Ensure the pads are sensitive enough to capture your playing style and provide a satisfying response when pressed.
Related Post:

Leave a Comment